Lessons I have learned from adding FAQ schema: A test of 1,000 keywords
“We’ve passed a milestone in Google’s evolution from search engine to walled-garden…” said Rand Fishkin in his recent research. You might have already seen that Google organic click-thru rate is shrinking at alarming rates in the last three years.
Whether your CTR improved or stayed the same over time, I am sure you have been alarmed by those stats.
This is in line with what Fishkin found out, which is an effort to keep users on search results by serving answers directly on Google properties. Also, there are various opinions in the SEO community about the whole issue.
I will tell you where I stand, and hope my case study will bring new light on FAQ Schema.
Benefit 1: Improving organic CTR
Before digging into the details of my case study, let’s review how to improve click-thru rate with FAQ schema.
If you search for “how to increase your CTR,” you’ll find ideas that are outdated. Some of them might still work in 2019, while others will be completely useless.
Here are the typical suggestions:
- Improve page titles
- Improve URL structure
- Improve meta descriptions
The problem with these suggestions is that if you are not already ranking on the top three organic positions, it’s the equivalent of (almost) ranking on page two.
Think about it, on SERP we already have four paid ads on top taking all the space, then you have the local pack and position one finally can be seen on the horizon.
This is how typically the modern SERP looks like:
What can marketers do?
This is when FAQ Schema can come to help.
Benefit 2: Gain more SERP real estate
Another benefit of FAQ Schema is that if implemented correctly, they can take up so much space in search results to push down all your competitors.
This is ultimately what will gain you more clicks whether or not you add hyperlinks into the FAQs. In my case these were completely useless in terms of improved CTR.
The case study: How can FAQ snippets help improve CTR?
In the case study of my company’s website, I used FAQ Schema on one landing page. I almost doubled the CTR from 1.82% to 2.75% (51% uplift) in less than three months. This is a big uplift in a sample of 1,000 keywords. I have gained more than 2,000 clicks for a set of keywords that were bringing normally only 1,000 clicks before I added the FAQ snippets.
As I said before, the reason why this happened is not that I added hyperlinks, but simply because FAQ snippets take more space in SERP.
My test also uncovered other interesting insights about users’ behaviors and keywords type.
Long answers vs. short answers
Since my snippets had long answers, they have taken lots of space and contained a lot of information. This is one of the beauties of FAQ snippets. As long as Google will allow long answers, I would advise using this opportunity.
I haven’t seen any CR decrease because of long answers.
I haven’t seen a decrease in CTR despite the long answers in the snippets. I believe this can be explained by the fact the keywords were transactional, not informational. People still need to click on the website and perform a conversion.
If the keywords would have been informational, I doubt I would have seen a CTR increase. But this is something that I will test next time.
In my test, I didn’t notice an increase in clicks from FAQ snippets. Despite this, an increase on CTR was seen. I can only assume people were clicking on the SERP result page. Others have advised adding internal links in the FAQs to secure clicks, but in my test this wasn’t an issue.